Third-party risk management for community banks: the 2023 guidance, the 2026 proposals and three free templates
The 2023 interagency guidance still applies while the agencies take comments on its replacement. These templates work under both texts: a SOC report review, a side-by-side crosswalk and a vendor tiering worksheet.
Where the guidance stands
The Interagency Guidance on Third-Party Relationships: Risk Management was issued by the Federal Reserve Board, the FDIC and the OCC, final as of June 6, 2023 and published June 9, 2023 (88 FR 37920). In May 2024 the same three agencies published Third-Party Risk Management: A Guide for Community Banks, which shows how a community bank may apply it at each stage of a relationship.
On September 15, 2026 two proposals were published. The OCC, the Board, the FDIC and the NCUA proposed Third-Party Risk Management Guidance for all the organizations they supervise (91 FR 58536), which, if finalized, would replace the 2023 guidance and the supplemental resources that go with it, including the 2024 community bank guide. The Board separately proposed a Third-Party Risk Management Guide for Traditional Community Banking Organizations (91 FR 58438). On November 13, 2026 the agencies extended the comment period on both to December 16, 2026.
Both 2026 documents are proposals. Until a final text is issued, the 2023 guidance is the one in effect; the steps under it are in our third-party risk management checklist, and the proposals are explained in our explainer.
What the proposals would change for a community bank
- Four components instead of a life cycle. The proposed guidance presents risk identification and assessment, risk oversight proportionate to significance, residual risk acceptance, and governance [3]. Due diligence, contract negotiation, ongoing monitoring and termination sit inside the second component.
- A simpler inventory is enough. The proposal says a community bank may benefit from a simpler or streamlined inventory, and that banks may decide not to keep extensive inventories of relationships posing limited risk, such as administrative or clerical tasks, professional support services including audit and legal advice, and office support services including physical security [3].
- Higher risk is judged by harm and likelihood. Instead of the 2023 idea of critical activities, the proposal describes higher-risk relationships as those that, if something goes wrong, could cause a non-trivial violation of law or regulation, material harm to the bank’s financial condition or a significant disruption to its operations or customers, where there is a material likelihood that this happens under current or reasonably foreseeable conditions [3].
- Residual risk can be accepted. The agencies say they do not expect banks to eliminate third-party risk, and recognize that a bank may lack the bargaining power to conduct sufficient due diligence, negotiate customized contract terms or monitor in depth [3].
- Non-enforceable. The proposal states that it does not set enforceable standards and that non-compliance with it will not result in supervisory action, while the agencies may still act on violations of law, unsafe or unsound practices or other material risks from insufficient management of third-party risk [3].
The Board’s community bank guide is for banking organizations with less than $30 billion in assets that focus on serving their local communities. It discusses four overarching topics (operational resilience, system and information security, compliance with rules and regulations, and financial resilience) and eight kinds of provider: core, IT infrastructure, cybersecurity, payment processing and digital banking, loan management systems, card issuing and processing, BSA/AML and financial crime platforms, and fraud prevention and detection. It names SSAE 18 SOC reports first among the independent assessments a community bank may rely on to judge a provider’s operational resilience [4].
What stays the same
The responsibility does not move. The 2023 guidance states that using third parties does not diminish or remove a banking organization’s responsibility to perform activities safely and soundly and in compliance with the law [1], and the proposal keeps that principle [3]. Both texts ask for oversight scaled to risk, so the inventory, the risk tiers and the evidence of each review carry over whichever text is final. Credit unions can refer to the NCUA’s Letter to Credit Unions 07-CU-13; the NCUA joins the 2026 proposal [3].
The templates
Free to use and adapt. Each opens as a page you can read and print, and each table also downloads as a CSV file.
SOC report review template
One worksheet per report: what it covers, what the auditor found, which controls the report expects your bank to run, and what you will follow up.
Open the templateThird-party risk guidance crosswalk: the 2023 interagency guidance and the 2026 proposal
Topic by topic, what the 2023 guidance says, what the September 2026 proposal would say instead, and a blank column for what that means for your program.
Open the templateVendor risk tiering worksheet
Questions taken from the agencies' own texts, answered once per relationship, and a tier table whose definitions your bank writes itself.
Open the template
Choosing software for this work? Read the buyer’s guide: How to evaluate vendor and third-party risk management software.
This is general information, not legal advice. For what a rule requires of your organization, read the rule itself or ask your counsel.