Third-party risk guidance crosswalk: the 2023 interagency guidance and the 2026 proposal
Topic by topic, what the 2023 guidance says, what the September 2026 proposal would say instead, and a blank column for what that means for your program.
The 2023 guidance is organized around the life cycle of a relationship, with governance around it [1]. The September 2026 proposal keeps the principle that responsibility stays with the bank, but reorganizes the text around four components and states that it is not enforceable [3]. Comments are due December 16, 2026 [5]. The proposal may change before it is final, so read this crosswalk as a map of the two texts as published, not of the final rule.
How to use it
- Read each row across: the topic, the 2023 text, the 2026 proposal.
- In the last column, write what your current policy or procedure says on that topic, and whether you would change it if the proposal became final as published.
- Keep the completed crosswalk with your comment letter work, or with the policy review your board receives.
The template
Download as CSV Opens in Excel, Numbers or Google Sheets. To print, use your browser’s Print command.
| Topic | 2023 interagency guidance | 2026 proposal (as published) | What our program does now, and what we would change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shape and status | |||
| Structure | A life cycle for each relationship: planning; due diligence and selection; contract negotiation; ongoing monitoring; termination. Governance around it: oversight and accountability, independent reviews, documentation and reporting. | Four components: risk identification and assessment; risk oversight proportionate to significance (due diligence, contracts, monitoring, termination, cross-cutting topics); residual risk acceptance; governance. | |
| Status | Final guidance, in effect since June 6, 2023. Principles-based, with illustrative examples. | A proposal. States it does not set enforceable standards and that non-compliance with it will not result in supervisory action; the agencies may still act on violations of law, unsafe or unsound practices or other material risks. | |
| Who issued it | Federal Reserve Board, FDIC and OCC. Credit unions refer to NCUA Letter 07-CU-13. | OCC, Federal Reserve Board, FDIC and NCUA. Covers insured credit unions as well as banks. | |
| What it would replace | Replaced each agency's earlier general third-party guidance. | If finalized, replaces the 2023 guidance and its supplemental resources: OCC Bulletin 2002-16 on foreign-based service providers, the July 25, 2024 joint statement on arrangements to deliver deposit products, and the May 2024 guide for community banks. | |
| Which relationships, and how much oversight | |||
| What counts as a relationship | Any business arrangement between a banking organization and another entity, by contract or otherwise; a relationship may exist without a contract or remuneration. | A business arrangement for products, services or other activities that support the bank. Use of subcontractors alone does not typically create an independent relationship or a presumption of direct oversight of subcontractors. Asks whether the guidance should cover only third parties under a written agreement. | |
| Inventory | Among the documentation and reporting practices it describes: a current inventory of all third-party relationships (and, as appropriate, related subcontractors) that identifies those associated with higher-risk activities, including critical activities. | An inventory may be useful; a community bank may benefit from a simpler or streamlined one. Banks may decide not to keep extensive inventories of limited-risk relationships such as clerical tasks, audit and legal advice, and office support including physical security. | |
| Which relationships get more oversight | Relationships that support higher-risk activities, including critical activities: those that could cause significant risk if the third party fails, have significant customer impacts, or significantly affect financial condition or operations. | Higher-risk relationships: those where something going wrong could cause a non-trivial violation of law, material financial harm or significant disruption to operations or customers, with a material likelihood under current or reasonably foreseeable conditions. | |
| Board involvement | For critical activities, plans may be presented to and approved by the board or a board committee. | Governance practices may include appropriate reporting to senior management and the board; there is no one right way to structure them. | |
| Oversight in practice | |||
| Due diligence | Scaled to the risk of the activity; the guidance lists many factors to consider. | The amount warranted depends on the risk of the relationship; for lower-risk relationships a bank may rely on less detailed information or on public or alternative sources. | |
| Contracts and bargaining power | Contract negotiation is a stage of the life cycle, with considerations listed. | Recognizes that a bank may lack bargaining power to negotiate customized terms, conduct full due diligence or monitor in depth, and may still proceed. | |
| Residual risk | Not a separate topic. | A component of its own: the agencies do not expect banks to eliminate third-party risk; a relationship may be beneficial and necessary even where a risk cannot be significantly mitigated. | |
| Independent reviews | Part of governance. | Governance practices may include periodic independent reviews of the program's effectiveness. | |
Summaries in this table are ours, made from the published texts listed under Sources; where it matters, read the paragraph in the source itself.
This is general information, not legal advice. For what a rule requires of your organization, read the rule itself or ask your counsel.