Vendor risk tiering worksheet
Questions taken from the agencies' own texts, answered once per relationship, and a tier table whose definitions your bank writes itself.
Both the 2023 guidance and the 2026 proposal ask for more rigorous oversight of riskier relationships and less for the rest [1] [3]. Neither sets tiers or scores for you: each bank decides what is higher risk for its own business [3]. This worksheet collects the questions the texts themselves raise, so the tier you assign can be traced back to them.
How to use it
- Write your tier definitions first, in the last group of rows: how many tiers, what puts a relationship in each, and what each tier means for due diligence and review frequency. Your board or risk committee approves them.
- For each relationship, answer the questions with yes, no or not known, with a line of evidence. Not known is a follow-up, not a no.
- Assign the tier from your definitions and record who decided and when. Reassess when the relationship changes, for example a new or expanded contract or a concern found in monitoring [3].
The template
Download as CSV Opens in Excel, Numbers or Google Sheets. To print, use your browser’s Print command.
| Question | Where it comes from | Answer (yes, no, not known) | Evidence or note |
|---|---|---|---|
| What the third party touches | |||
| Does the third party have access to sensitive data, including customer data? | 2024 community bank guide, factors for higher-risk activities | ||
| Does it process transactions for the bank or its customers? | 2024 community bank guide, factors for higher-risk activities | ||
| Does it provide essential technology or business services? | 2024 community bank guide, factors for higher-risk activities | ||
| Does it connect to bank systems or networks that hold critical data, and is that access segmented? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment (footnote on system access) | ||
| What happens if it fails | |||
| Could its failure to meet expectations cause the bank significant risk? | 2023 guidance and 2024 guide, characteristics of critical activities | ||
| Would a failure have significant customer impacts? | 2023 guidance and 2024 guide, characteristics of critical activities | ||
| Would a failure significantly affect the bank's financial condition or operations? | 2023 guidance and 2024 guide, characteristics of critical activities | ||
| Could a disruption, attack or breach of contract cause a non-trivial violation of law or regulation? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment | ||
| Is there a material likelihood of that harm under current or reasonably foreseeable conditions? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment | ||
| How much the bank relies on it | |||
| Does the bank rely on it for extensive services, so that concentration risk arises? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment (footnote on concentration) | ||
| Does it serve most of the bank's business, or a limited portion? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment (footnote on core processors) | ||
| Is it an affiliate operating within an enterprise-wide risk management framework the bank knows? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment | ||
| Is it itself regulated or supervised, and does that regulation bear on the risks that matter here? | 2026 proposal, risk assessment (regulation is not a substitute for the bank's own oversight) | ||
| Your tier definitions (complete once, approved by your committee) | |||
| Tier 1 (highest) | Your definition: what puts a relationship here; due diligence expected; review frequency | ||
| Tier 2 | Your definition: what puts a relationship here; due diligence expected; review frequency | ||
| Tier 3 | Your definition: what puts a relationship here; due diligence expected; review frequency | ||
| Limited risk, kept off the detailed inventory | Your definition, if your bank uses this option under the 2026 proposal once final | ||
| Decision | |||
| Tier assigned | Your definitions above | ||
| Decided by, and date | Your policy | ||
| Next reassessment, or the event that triggers one | Your definitions above; 2026 proposal, reassessment | ||
The worksheet does not score or weigh the answers for you. If your bank uses points and thresholds, set them in your own definitions.
This is general information, not legal advice. For what a rule requires of your organization, read the rule itself or ask your counsel.