The EMTALA on-call list: what CMS requires, a survey-ready checklist and a call-equity calculator

A hospital must keep a list of the physicians on call to stabilize emergency patients, and written policies for when the list fails. What the regulations and CMS's interpretive guidelines ask for, and two tools to check yours.

What the regulations require

Under its Medicare provider agreement, a hospital must maintain “an on-call list of physicians who are on the hospital’s medical staff or who have privileges at the hospital, or who are on the staff or have privileges at another hospital participating in a formal community call plan”, available to provide the treatment needed after the initial examination to stabilize individuals with emergency medical conditions, in accordance with the resources available to the hospital [1].

The EMTALA regulation adds that the hospital must have written policies and procedures to respond when a particular specialty is not available or the on-call physician cannot respond because of circumstances beyond the physician’s control, and to make sure emergency services are available if it permits on-call physicians to schedule elective surgery while on call, permits simultaneous on-call duties, or takes part in a formal community call plan [2]. A community call plan must contain six elements set out in the regulation, including a signature from each participating hospital and an annual assessment [2].

CMS’s interpretive guidelines note that the on-call list requirement applies to hospitals with dedicated emergency departments and also to hospitals that must accept appropriate transfers under EMTALA [3].

What CMS surveyors look for

The interpretive guidelines for tag A-2404 in Appendix V of the State Operations Manual explain how surveyors read the requirement [3]:

  • Names, not groups. Physician group names are not acceptable for identifying the on-call physician; individual physician names are to be listed with accurate contact information.
  • Current. The list must be up to date and accurately reflect the current privileges of the physicians on call.
  • History. Among the documents surveyors ask the hospital for at the entrance conference of an investigation are physician on-call lists for the past six months.
  • Back-up plans. If the hospital allows simultaneous call, elective procedures while on call or community call, it needs a back-up plan for each, and must be able to show that staff know and can carry out the back-up procedures.
  • Response time. An on-call physician asked to appear must come in person within a reasonable time. CMS advises hospitals to set specific guidelines in their policies, for example the maximum number of minutes between a request and the physician’s appearance.

How much coverage, and shared how

CMS does not set a ratio of physicians to on-call days and has no rule that three physicians in a specialty means round-the-clock coverage. It expects a hospital to strive to provide adequate specialty coverage consistent with its services and resources, and recognizes that it would not be prudent to expect one physician to be on call every day of the week, every week of the year [3]. There is no EMTALA requirement that every member of the medical staff take call, so exemptions, for example for senior physicians, are allowed, provided coverage stays adequate [3].

That leaves the split of call within a department to the department. The call-equity calculator below compares the calls each physician has taken with their share of the call pool, using the weights for weekends and holidays your department agrees, so a rota discussion can start from numbers rather than memory.

The templates

Free to use and adapt. Each opens as a page you can read and print, and each table also downloads as a CSV file.

  • Template and CSV

    EMTALA on-call list checklist

    Each item quotes or summarizes the regulation or CMS's interpretive guidelines, names the source, and leaves a column for the evidence your hospital would show a surveyor.

    Open the template
  • Calculator

    Call-equity calculator

    Enter each physician's share of the call pool and the calls they took; set what a weekend and a holiday are worth. The calculator shows who has taken more or less than their share.

    Open the template

This is general information, not legal advice. For what a rule requires of your organization, read the rule itself or ask your counsel.

Related Moraph software

If you would rather keep this in software

The templates work on their own, on paper or in a spreadsheet. Each product page lists what the product does, what it does not do, and how to arrange a demonstration.

More free templates: Free templates. Evaluating software? Buyer’s guides and How to buy.